Review: The Five by Hallie Rubenhold

I’m just going to say this right up front: The Five: The Lives of Jack the Ripper’s Women by Hallie Rubenhold is going to be one of my favorite books of the year. I got it from the library (I was the first in line to get it!) and I’ll probably purchase it just so I have it on my shelf, I loved it that much.

Finding details about the personal lives of royal women from the past is hard enough, so I can’t even imagine the amount of digging Rubenhold would have done to research and compile biographies of the five women now known as Jack the Ripper’s “canonical five.” Crafting these bits and pieces together into vivid stories really brought these women to life.

They weren’t just unfortunate victims. They were people with loved ones and friends and real lives. Driving this point home was one of Rubenhold’s goals with this book and she accomplishes it by leaps and bounds on every page.

This book is full of the “daily life” historical detail that I loveThe Five, without going into the bloody details featured in every other Jack the Ripper book on the market, also discusses the assumption that was made about the five at the time and has just been carried on for over 100 years:

There is no evidence that three of the five “canonical five” (Mary Ann Nichols, Catherine Eddowes, and Annie Chapman) were sex workers.

To the newspapers and police investigating the case, a poor woman who found herself sleeping on the street was obviously a “fallen woman” so they were reported as being such. Like so many others, I just assumed that was accurate but because of Rubenhold’s arguments, I can confidently say assuming they were sex workers was the wrong thing to do and likely hurt the original investigation.

I adore Rubenhold for withholding the gory details unless necessary and I respect her so much for leaving out details about the monster that brutally took the lives of these women. This book is long overdue and an incredibly important book for women’s history. For fans of Victorian England and Ripperology, it’s a must-read.

The Five doesn’t describe how they died. It describes how they lived. It’s exceptional.

RATING: 5/5 stars

jillianne hamilton headshotJillianne Hamilton is an author, history enthusiast, book lover, and graphic designer. Her debut novel, Molly Miranda: Thief for Hire, was shortlisted for the 2016 Prince Edward Island Book Award. Her debut non-fiction book, The Lazy Historian's Guide to the Wives of Henry VIII is now available. She lives in Charlottetown on Canada's beautiful east coast and is working on her debut historical fiction novel.
Author WebsiteBlogFacebookTwitterInstagram


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.